Tuesday, May 17, 2016

Gracefully Grayson-Ami Polansky

Gracefully Grayson-Ami Polansky

the facts
satisfaction: up
pages: 250
gender: F
nationality: USA
year: 2015
Middle Grade

With the help of a play, Grayson is finally allowed to be herself.



Well, Polansky has certainly written a charming character in Grayson. She is alone and different, sustaining herself through fantasy and imagination. Polansky writes her with dignity and respect. Though the book does follow a very familiar narrative arc for the writing about young transgender protagonists, it does so in a...soft way. I can't really describe it to be honest but I have read a lot of novels about transgendered people and it is handled particularly delicately by Polansky. This is great for a book aimed for the younger set. For adults, this book might be a bit too light, a bit 'been there' and goodness, there was no attempt to challenge feminine stereotypes but for its intended audience? This is a lovely book in that it shows that even though your outside doesn't match your inside, there are people who will accept the inside. A reminder all too infrequently demonstrated and yes, sometimes, they are even adults AND children your own age! I also loved the portrayal of the play. The teacher was totally in Grayson's corner and the end result was beautiful for all of the pitfalls in the journey.

I think this is one of those books that for those at the end of their journeys and adults, it will seem too twee, too light, too conventional but it's so easy to forget how it is when you're young and you've never known this narrative could exist. And also, how the first step to challenging the gender you're supposed to represent is usually a somewhat naive sprint to the stereotypes surrounding the 'other gender'. This is not a book written for adult YA readers but rather for the middle school kids themselves.

No comments:

Post a Comment